A case for making getting dressed an imaginative exercise.

Published
For Michelle Li, getting dressed is an exercise in imagination. The New York-based writer, stylist, and brand consultant has spent much of her life documenting what she wears, what she wants, and how she feels about it. After years working in fashion editorial, Michelle launched Good Fantasy, a Substack devoted to secondhand treasures and the pleasure of wearing what you already own.
Michelle’s style is almost daunting to describe. There's something both magical and tactical about the way she dresses. It’s unforced and unconcerned with “trends.” In my girls’ group chat, we attempted to put it into words. “Tomboy fairy princess,” “down bitch,” and “rare vibe” were all floated. When Ali Royals’ mom—the very stylish Joan Royals—met Michelle, she talked about her outfit for three days afterward. Ella Emhoff called her “every influencer's favorite influencer.”
To me, Michelle is the best-dressed girl at the party. She pairs things I've never seen paired before, in ways I wouldn't have thought to try. Her style isn't something you can learn, though I remain convinced that if I look at enough of her outfits, some of it might eventually rub off on me.
On Good Fantasy, Michelle is generous with her secrets. She shares what she's searching for, how she finds it, what she actually wears, and how she puts it all together. I spoke with her about the romance of secondhand clothing, the pleasure of wanting things, and why some fantasies might be better left unrealized.

Gutes Guterman: Do you think getting dressed is an act of fantasy?
Michelle Li: Yes, getting dressed is an act of fantasy. It can bring our fantasy into something tangible. I think that’s what is so great about getting dressed—it can be a combination of dressing for who we are, who we want to be, and even revisiting who we used to be. I love when outfits are a random amalgamation of all of that, and that’s what makes them personal. The heels might represent who we want to be, the sweatpants where we are now, and the sunglasses who we used to be.
GG: Is personal style about discovering who you are or inventing someone you'd rather be?
ML: Personal style is about discovering who you are and evolving into who you want to be, not someone you'd rather be! It’s important to know yourself and be comfortable in your own skin, and then continue to challenge your creativity in personal style to become who you want to be.
GG: There's something kind of romantic about secondhand clothing. You're buying something that already had a life before you. Do you ever fantasize about the people who owned your clothes before you?
ML: Definitely! In my fantasies, they are always fancy, single, independent older women in Texas or Florida. I don’t know why. Maybe it’s some kind of secondhand alter ego. I make up stories about them, like they’re ornithologists who love Prada, but they don’t have kids, so they’re selling their clothes on Poshmark. I purposely don’t look at the seller profiles because I want my mind to make up the stories!
GG: Does wanting something make it more beautiful? Have you ever wanted an item so badly that, once you finally got it, the fantasy was better than the reality?
ML: I’ve experienced both. I’ve wanted something and searched for a long time, and because it lived up to the fantasy, I cherish it even more. But I’ve also put too much pressure on an item, thinking it would fix my problems and I would never need to buy another jacket again! And of course, no tangible object has that kind of power. I set it up for failure.
GG: Having worked both inside the industry and as someone influencing what other people buy, has your relationship to desire changed?
ML: It’s changed what I let myself desire. Like I said before, I don’t put as much pressure on what I buy. I have a more realistic outlook on how much happiness an object will give me. And I’ve definitely stopped equating a higher price with more fulfillment. That idea has completely gone out the window.
GG: Do you think realizing a fantasy makes you more ambitious, or does it make you question what you wanted in the first place?
ML: For me, realizing a fantasy has made me more ambitious. It’s made me realize I’m more capable than I thought, and I can let myself have bigger fantasies for my life. Also, seeing older women lead these exciting, independent lives has made me fantasize about all aspects of my life, not just my career.
GG: Do you believe in manifestation, or do you think wanting something badly enough is mostly a recipe for disappointment?
ML: I believe in manifestation, but I never actually do it. I admire people who can manifest things, but as I enter my 30s, I am really coming to enjoy being content with what I have. That’s something that I’ve had to learn and understand. Wanting something badly is definitely a recipe for disappointment! The more I want something, the less likely the universe is to give it to me. The best things in my life have happened when I wasn’t looking for them.
GG: What's your ultimate fantasy?
ML: I have a funny fantasy I've had since I was a kid. It was that while I was shopping at Nordstrom or TJ Maxx, someone would come up to me and offer to buy me whatever I wanted from the store. So anytime I went shopping, I would always find the item I would choose in case that happened to me. It makes me smile now, always prepared for the fantasy to come true.
My ultimate fantasy now is to have a life doing only things I want to do. Never having to chase relevance or approvals or validation. That’s the real but impossible fantasy!!!!
GG: Do you think your younger self would be impressed by the person you've become? What would surprise her?
ML: I think my younger self would really love who I’ve become. I think she would be proud. She would probably be surprised by how I’ve confronted and learned to manage my anxiety and anger. Also, she would be surprised at how much I love being alone.




